Saturday, January 12, 2013

Real or Fake?

     In the book What Happened to Goodbye, by Sarah Dessen, Mclean has always been a girl who says she likes change.  After her parents got divorced and she went to live with her dad and ended up moving four times in two years!  And each time, she would create a new nickname and personality for herself.  It was only when she just recently moved and wasn't able to make a nickname that she realized she had to start living her life as herself, but found it to be very difficult.  This makes me think about being real or fake and how it affects your life.

     As I said, Mclean had always changed who she was when she moved to a new place.  For example, last time, she named herself Beth and decided to be that kind of person that everyone knew.  She joined every club, became friends with the popular cheerleaders and jocks, and appeared in almost every page of the yearbook.  She said that by changing herself, there was no confusion in her life and it was just easier for her to create a life for herself.  But in this new place she moved to, she didn't get a chance to figure out who she was going to be and found it very difficult.  For example, she didn't know who she'd be friends with, such as the jocks or the geeks.  Instead, friends found her by inviting her to sit with her or being the boy next door.  She also met Dave who introduced her to being herself and taking all of her life's problems in (such as how her mother divorced her dad to marry one of her idols) instead of creating a fresh start as if the past had never happened.  Mclean faced a lot of confusion from her feelings about Dave to telling her mother how she really felt.  And in the end, she realized it was okay, as she put it, "to have the world moving beneath me, a hand gripping mine, knowing if I fell, at least I wouldn't do it alone."  Overall, this makes me think that although it was harder for Mclean to live a "real" life, that doing so is better than putting on a fake smile and saying words you might never have wanted to say.  This is because life is supposed to be hard.  And sometimes, the best part of it is letting the world take its course and finding yourself.  Although being fake might be easier, as exemplified by Mclean, it may make you feel alone because no one knows the real you.  Just be yourself and if you fall, at least you might not do it alone.

12 comments:

  1. Great post Holly! I feel like you really made your point clear to the reader, which is very important. I agree with what your saying, its sometimes easier to be someone else than to be yourself. I think that Mclean didn't want to deal with her feelings and problems, so she just invented identities where she didn't have to. Also, great vocab (i.e. exemplified)! Maybe next time you could split your post up into more paragraphs as the last big one is hard to read.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Zoe, and yeah, I think McLean just didn't want to face her problems. Thanks for the advice too!

      Delete
  2. that was really good. i agree with you and zoe, its easier to hide behind a fake name and character than to be who you really are. and its easier to run away from problems than face them. however, its very important, i think, to at least acknowledge them. If Mclean had revealed who she really was from the beginning, she would have had a lean slate each time she moved to learn from her mistakes. I think that would have been beneficial to her.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I totally agree with you Joelle. However, I think that running away can seem easier at first, but results in a lot of complications when you decide to be yourself. Thanks for commenting!

      Delete
  3. Amazing post! I love that quote!! It really means a lot to me personally because being myself, I know that I have a great support system of friends backing me up. I've tried to act different before to become friends with someone who, in the end, didn't turn out to be a person I wanted to be friends with. Acting different hurts because you never become comfortable with that personality you are taking on, and can never have fun, when you're worried about what someone might think. If you can't be yourself around your friends, they shouldn't be your friends, and if you need to impress someone to feel welcome, that's wrong. I love my friends, and wouldn't be able to do anything without them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I agree with you. It can be very uncomfortable being someone your not.

      Delete
  4. This post is really, really good Holly! I can tell you really analyzed this and thought a TON about it. I agree a lot with what you wrote and thought it was really great. In the end, it is important just to be who you are and that is the best. And, as you said in your post, even though she didn't make up a new person and decide who she would be friends with in advance, she still made friends who cared about her for who she was. Great job!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for commenting! I believe caring friends are some of the best things in life.

      Delete
  5. This is a really good post, Holly! I agree with Josephine, anyone could tell you really thought a lot about this book, and you analyzed everything really well. I actually plan on getting this book, because I LOVE Sarah Dessen. And what you said at the end of the post, about life being hard and how you just have to let things take theor course, I totally agree with that! This was a really great post, Holly. Nice job!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! And if you like Sarah Dessen, you'll probably love this book. :)

      Delete
  6. This was a really good post. I agree with Josephine that how in the end it's important to be who you are that ends up being the best. I really like how you took this book and really went between the lines. I read this book before and really liked it. I completely agree about the part that you should be yourself and that if you fall you won't fall alone. It's a really important message. Anyway, I loved your post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The line " if I feel, at least I wouldn't fall alone," is one of my favorite lines of the book. Dessen always puts me in awe when she writes such deep and thoughtful lines.

      Delete